Innova/Innova Puppy/Canidae HELP

[shybird]

I have been feeding Innova adult to Kafer age 5 1/2 since Feb of this year and hav been very happy with the results. When I got Schatz, I put her on Innova puppy. My pet food dealer said that I could at anytime switch her to the adult food. She is now 7 1/2 months old. He feels that the adult food is so good that there is no need for their puppy line and that I am wasting money, because the puppy food is more expensive. See he isn't out to just make money. I still kept her on the puppy food.

So what does he now also carry along with the Innova that I have been so happy with? You guessed it...Canidae... Now what do I do? Do I go to the one Ranked Number One on this forum? Canidae. Or do I stay with Innova? And do I scrap the Puppy food? Or do I feed One brand one month then the other brand the next month going for an all over good food program? While I at this question He also carries Solid Gold....

What would you do? Besides BARF.. I looked at a raw chicken back and wing and heard my Dearly Departed Mother say..Never ever feed your dog chicken bones...I can't do it....

[Deborah Reid]

I am having a simular problem. I am currently feeding Innova, because I really liked the ingredients list, and have been adding in some BARF basics, but have heard so much about Canidae I am not sure which I should be feeding LOL.
I think we are torn like this because we very much want to feed out dogs the VERY BEST we can... but which is the *very best*?

[EKCoon]

I am not an expert at all, but I am getting ready to switch from Canidae to Innova. My male will eat anything, but my female hates to eat Canidae. It is a struggle to make her eat it. I say if your dogs are happy with Innova then why change? You may end up regretting it and wasting money ;)