At Petsmart I found these ultra durable toys that aren't made of rubber. My boy really loves squeakers, but unfortunately he also loves destroying all the soft toys that have squeakers. So I decided to try out this new toy I found. It is a soft toy, but really tough. Gary got the red lobster and we have already had it for a month. The claws still squeak too! There are other critters though, give them a try! Here's a link so you can see what they look like, but I bought mine from petsmart.
Amazon.com: Tuffies Ultimate Sea Creature Lobster Dog Toy (Red): Kitchen & Dining