[SABELLESMOM]

I've had both! Either breed, well bred is: highly intellegent, stunningly beautiful, and happiest when with their people! Both are intuitive, loving, and loyal. My GSD's (Heidi, Fritz, Ginger and Race) involved a bit more grooming and shed more than any of my Rottweilers (Jazmine, Sable and Rave).

My Rottn's are a bit more comical. They seem to have a sense of humor, actually. They pull pranks and walk off grinning happily to themselves. My GSD's? Well it was more of an individual thing. Heidi was the only one with a joke on her mind.

The GSD's were a bit more businesslike...all the time, not just "on" during training. My Rottie, Raven, and my GSD, Heidi are/were intense. Rave is the most intense dog I've ever known! She's the only one completely clicker trained. She "locks on" practically. Then shows "pride" when she figures out what is wanted. Then never forgets! A real dream dog. But who's to say, had I understood clicker training, then...that my GSD's wouldn't have done just as well.

GSD's probably fare a bit better in the public opinion category. There are many who think Rottie's turn on their owners and eat children. Have a sense of humor...stupidity is always about.

So, investigate! You've selected two of my favorite breeds. I'm certain you would be happy with either. Training is essential. They don't come pretrained and with perfect manners. You have to be willing to take that on. You sound like you are looking forward to that part!