Congrats on the reserve!
If it makes you feel any better I had two judges tell my handler that Bella was overweight (which she was).
Now that I have a better eye, I am not sure why some judges place dogs the way they do but my guess is that at least some of the all breed judges either have no clue what the standard is or they are looking at the wrong end of the leash
(And in the spirit of full disclosure I know Bella was the recipient of at least one win for that exact reason
.)