I know dogs that work in schutzhund that can't herd, can't get a CGN/CGC, can't get a CH, can't work in agility, can’t work in (CKC/AKC) obedience, etc. While I agree that schutzhund gives a wonderful outlet to a drivey dog, are our dogs really supposed to be *that* drivey? That they can't work in any other venue than when they're allowed to go Mach 2 with their butts on fire by themselves out in a field?
An excerpt from the CKC standard for the Rottweiler Temperament:
Quote:
Temperament:
The Rottweiler should possess a fearless expression with a self-assured aloofness that does not lend itself to immediate and indiscriminate friendships. He has a strong willingness to work. In examining a Rottweiler, one should bear in mind that this dog reacts with alertness to his master and his surroundings, and in performing his function in life, the Rottweiler is not expected to submit to excessive handling by strangers.
|
Many (read not all) of the 'drivey' schutzhund dogs are just roaring to go. Which to me, doesn't exemplify the 'self-assured aloofness' referenced. That to me means a quiet confidence that they can walk into any situation and own it. Without a need to be over the top, unable to simply oversee their new domain.
Now granted, my experience with Schutzhund is limited. But of the few schutzhund dogs that I've been truly impressed by - were also able to work in multiple venues rather than just the one alone.
We have to be careful that we keep the versatility in our breed. To accept only one venue to be the 'judge' of our breed is dangerous. Our dogs were bred to be jacks of all trades. Pets, protectors, herders, able to work in busy city centers without being distracted by the people/dogs/animals, able to work independently and companions for all ages of the family. Other breeds have found themselves bred into corners because they put too much emphasis on one sport or use. We should be mindful not to let that happen to us. JMHO.
The disclaimer of course is that we’re not close to ‘only’ breeding for schutzhund. But ‘specializing’ our breed for *any* one thing, is something we should actively and consciously avoid.