[moondog]

Originally Posted by Judi W

Many knowlegeable people prefer that any desexing take place after physical maturity. This makes a considerable difference regarding spay incontinence and is also discovered to be a possible influence on osteo and other skeletal provisions.

Originally Posted by Rotty4Me

I understand this, but do not agree with a pet dog being allowed to come into heat before neutering

This is where it came from. The good reasons for a later spay were given, and you "understand, but don't agree" that these reasons should have an effect on spay decisions for pet dogs, even if their welfare is at risk.

Originally Posted by Rotty4Me

This is incredibly hurtful.

I have not responded to this thread because I was afraid of what I might say, but now I'm going to say it. Hurtful? To whom? I am Patti, Pet Dog Owner. I recently had to put my TREASURED companion, Luna, The Pet Dog, to sleep because of osteosarcoma. Who got hurt here? Luna DIED, as have many other Pet Dogs who didn't deserve to succumb to this disease. If waiting to spay her would have spared her the PAIN and DEATH of this terrible disease, who are you to say that shouldn't be done??? I'm sorry, but you really brought out the mama bear in me with this. The hair is bristling on the back of my neck.

Originally Posted by Rotty4Me

The average pet owner is not as aware or understanding of the necessary steps to take with an intact dog. And isn't there something to be said about the more indepth the surgery becomes once they have had cycles?

Then the average pet owner needs more education and the average breeder needs to be more careful where they place their puppies, don't you think? I'll take my chances with a skilled surgeon over the heartbreak of osteosarcoma any day.