[bump]

All 4 of my dogs herd, everyday. I have 3 bcs and the rottie. Very different herding styles, and I use them for different tasks to accomodate. The bcs are very self-directed dogs, who can work at long distance from me. I use them to move large numbers of hoof stock, primarily sheep, around the pastures. I also use them to gather and drive the sheep into pens, trucks, ponds, etc. for transport, dipping, shearing.

The rottie dog needs much more direction to work. You need to be right there telling him what to do. I use him primarily around the near lots to manage smaller groups or single animals. He's great for cutting out and holding cattle or hogs, not so great moving more than 4-5 animals at a time.

The rottie was originally brought into our family as the "house dog", primarily a companion. But, I couldn't stand to see such a nice and useful animal lounging around. Training him to herd has improved his physical condition immensely, improved our ability to communicate and has really bonded him to the family. Much calmer and just better since he's got a job.

So, if you want to herd, go for it! You'll see nothing but positive results.

(Get your dog some booties. All of mine wear raw spots on their pads from time to time.)