My point was more to drive home the point that this person would not enjoy having a dog. Obviously this poster has tried telling her friend that a puppy should not be given as a gift. He's not listening!!
So I suggested that a demonstration of "a day in the life of" is in order. :p
Heck, I have little kibble bits and hair bunnies rolling on the floor with my 2 cats! If you don't like cats (and mine are particularly friendly to those who don't ;)), my home will convince you that you're right!! ;) hehehe
If her friend can't convince him to change his mind, maybe his boyfriend's reaction to a real dog situation will. ;)
Some people will do whatever they want, regardless of how much wonderful and correct advice they are given. Sometimes it takes an 'in your face' or 'this is reality' approach to bring it home for them.